So that is just the button slightly turning, but I was thinking of using the whole vanity in the shot, so it would look like this:
And with the screen and lights moving it will be more apparent that it's turning. Right now I have the text on a layer in After Effects, but I plan on doing it on a plane in Maya so that it will move perfectly with the button. Also, where the titles are (e.g. - Cast) will be a hand painted text, done by Lauren, that matches the title.
I could also render everything different (maybe solid colors) if we want more of a 2D credit look.
I was thinking to move to the next button would just be a 5 to 8 frame pan.